Template:Make Believe reviews
| Reviewer | Rating | Review date | Author |
|---|---|---|---|
| Metacritic | Continuous | Average score of collected album reviews | |
| Allmusic | Not listed | Stephen Thomas Erlewine | |
| Blender | Not listed | Chris Norris | |
| Dot Music | May 16, 2005 | Chris Heath | |
| E! Online | Not listed | Not listed | |
| The Guardian | May 5, 2005 | Dave Simpson | |
| IGN | May 9, 2005 (updated May 19, 2012) | "JR" | |
| NME | No rating given | September 12, 2005 | Ian Winwood |
| Pitchfork Media | May 8, 2005 | Rob Mitchum | |
| Rolling Stone | May 19, 2005 | Rob Sheffield | |
| Stylus | May 13, 2005 | Charles Merwin |