Jump to content

Undone - The Sweater Song: Difference between revisions

Cleaned up page
(→‎Tracklist: Created table)
(Cleaned up page)
Line 62: Line 62:
*''[[Not Alone: Rivers Cuomo & Friends Live at Fingerprints]]'' (Live)
*''[[Not Alone: Rivers Cuomo & Friends Live at Fingerprints]]'' (Live)
*[[List of Official Bootlegs|Several Official Bootlegs]] (Live Version)
*[[List of Official Bootlegs|Several Official Bootlegs]] (Live Version)
===MP3 Previews===
''<small>Source is www.LastFM.com unless otherwise stated</small>''
*[http://play.last.fm/preview/26139.mp3 Album version]
*[http://play.last.fm/preview/3472892.mp3 ''The Kitchen Tape'' demo version]
==Overview==
==Overview==
Lead singer [[Rivers Cuomo]] has commented many times on this song. He said of the song, "I took typing, Psych 101, and English 101 that semester. It was in my English class that I heard the analogy of the unraveling sweater. Dr. Eisenstein used the image to demonstrate the effectiveness of focused [http://thesisstatementmaker.com/thesis-statement.html thesis statement] in an essay. “All I have to do is hold a single thread in your sweater and it will unravel as you walk away.
Lead singer [[Rivers Cuomo]] has commented many times on the song's inception. Said Cuomo, "I took typing, Psych 101, and English 101 that semester. It was in my English class that I heard the analogy of the unraveling sweater. Dr. Eisenstein used the image to demonstrate the effectiveness of focused thesis statement in an essay. 'All I have to do is hold a single thread in your sweater and it will unravel as you walk away.' [https://www.rollingstone.com/music/music-lists/readers-poll-the-10-best-weezer-songs-23051/4-undone-the-sweater-song-253809/]" Additionally, Cuomo has stated, "'Undone' is the feeling you get when the train stops and the little guy comes knockin' on your door. It was supposed to be a sad song, but everyone thinks it’s hilarious."
 
Additionally Cuomo has stated, "'Undone' is the feeling you get when the train stops and the little guy comes knockin' on your door. It was supposed to be a sad song, but everyone thinks it’s hilarious."
 
The original concept for the dialogue spoken in the song was to juxtapose an upbeat person and a depressed person having a conversation.  At some point during the recording of various demos of the song early in the band's existence, they decided to allow longtime friend of the band, [[Karl Koch|Karl]], to insert various sound clips into the song, creating a collage of left-and-right-speaker nonsense.  This concept was carried through the recording of ''[[The Blue Album]]'', but [[Geffen Records]] were wary of the cost of licensing the samples, and put a halt to that version.  In the eleventh hour, a spoken version of dialogue was recorded at the Amherst house, by then-bassist [[Matt Sharp]] and Karl, as well as an "intermission" set of dialogue between Karl and one of the founding members of Weezer's official fan club and early supporter of the band, [[Mykel and Carli Allan|Mykel Allan]].  The tapes were then sent overnight to New York to be 'flown in' to the final mix. Live, these sections usually feature the band talking or quoting other songs.
 
During live performances in 2005, the band would often invite a fan up to play the acoustic guitar part of "Undone" with the band. On the last night of the [[Foozer]] tour, Foo Fighters frontman Dave Grohl played the guitar part.
 
==Influences==
Rivers Cuomo stated in an interview that the song got influence from Sanitarium by Metallica and I Bleed by the Pixies.


<youtube>kqGWgSl9gAc</youtube>
In [[2009]], Cuomo admitted to Rolling Stone that "Undone" was an "almost complete rip-off" of "[https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V6Dfo4zDduI Sanitarium]" by the band Metallica. Said Cuomo, "I was trying to write a Velvet Underground-type song because I was super into them, and I came up with that guitar riff. I just picked up that acoustic guitar and the first thing I played was that riff. And it just feels so classic to me, even now when the band starts to play it, it just takes over the energy in the room and you’re just transported into the world of Weezer. It wasn’t until years after I wrote it that I realized it’s almost a complete rip-off of ‘Sanitarium’ by Metallica. It just perfectly encapsulates Weezer to me – you’re trying to be cool like Velvet Underground but your metal roots just pump through unconsciously."
<youtube>V6Dfo4zDduI</youtube>


Early concepts for the dialogue sections in the song was to utilize a sound collage assembled by longtime friend of the band, [[Karl Koch]]. This concept was carried through the recording of ''[[The Blue Album]]'', but [[Geffen Records]] were wary of the cost of licensing the samples, and put a halt to that version. Late in the album's production, a spoken version of dialogue was recorded at the Amherst house, by bassist [[Matt Sharp]] and Koch, as well as a dialogue between Koch and [[Mykel and Carli Allan|Mykel Allan]]. The tapes were then sent overnight to New York to be 'flown in' to the final mix. When performed live, these sections typically featured improvised banter by the band. In the 2010s, however, the band began simply playing a recording of the dialogue heard on the album version.
==Music Video==
==Music Video==
The music video for "Undone" was Weezer's first music video. According to ''Rivers' Edge: The Weezer Story'' by John D. Luerssen, the band insisted that the video not have anything to do with a sweater.  Yet, Geffen received twenty five treatments for the video, all involving sweaters, including one in which the band played in a sweater factory, and another wherein all four band members were together in one giant sweater.  The video marks one of the early directorial efforts of [[Spike Jonze]], whose pitch was simply "A blue stage, a steadicam, a pack of wild dogs."  The $60,000 video was shot on a steadicam in one unbroken take, featuring the band playing to a sped up version of the song. When played at a slower speed, the illusion is created that the band is playing the song in the correct time, yet moving in slow motion. The one take was shot over twenty five times and the final version is somewhere between shot #15 and shot #20, in which the band had abandoned the idea of taking the video seriously at all. The humor was brought on by the frustration of shooting the same take over and over to a sped up version of the song as well as the fact that one of the dogs defecated on [[Patrick Wilson]]'s bass drum pedal. The video became an instant hit on MTV.
The music video for "Undone" was Weezer's first music video. According to ''[[Rivers' Edge: The Weezer Story]]'' by John D. Luerssen, the band insisted that the video not have anything to do with a sweater.  Yet, Geffen received twenty five treatments for the video, all involving sweaters, including one in which the band played in a sweater factory, and another wherein all four band members were together in one giant sweater.  The video marks one of the early directorial efforts of [[Spike Jonze]], whose pitch was simply "A blue stage, a steadicam, a pack of wild dogs."  The $60,000 video was shot on a steadicam in one unbroken take, featuring the band playing to a sped up version of the song. When played at a slower speed, the illusion is created that the band is playing the song in the correct time, yet moving in slow motion. The one take was shot over twenty five times and the final version is somewhere between shot #15 and shot #20, in which the band had abandoned the idea of taking the video seriously at all. The humor was brought on by the frustration of shooting the same take over and over to a sped up version of the song as well as the fact that one of the dogs defecated on [[Patrick Wilson]]'s bass drum pedal. The video became an instant hit on MTV.


<youtube>LHQqqM5sr7g</youtube>
<youtube>LHQqqM5sr7g</youtube>


An alternate take of the video can be found on the band's ''[[Video Capture Device]]'' DVD.
An alternate take of the video can be found on the band's ''[[Video Capture Device]]'' DVD.


==Musical composition==
==Musical composition==
The song is notable for its seemingly basic chord progression which repeats through the verse and chorus of I, IV, V, IV.  However, the song does experience a key change modulation for the guitar solo after the second chorus, modulating from the key of F# Major to A Major, and thus following the same I, IV, V, IV progression. Also, the main guitar lead played over the chords of the intro and the outro contains a raised second pitch which resolves to the third. This accidental within the key gives the song an off-note and perceivably quirky feel to it.
The song is notable for its seemingly basic chord progression which repeats through the verse and chorus of I, IV, V, IV.  However, the song does experience a key change modulation for the guitar solo after the second chorus, modulating from the key of F# Major to A Major, and thus following the same I, IV, V, IV progression. Also, the main guitar lead played over the chords of the intro and the outro contains a raised second pitch which resolves to the third.
 
==Reception==
==Reception==
"Undone" is one of Weezer's most popular songs. It is praised as a quirky, nerdy song and helped align Weezer with the genre of nerd rock. It reached 57 on the US Billboard Hot 100 List of 1994. Die hard Weezer fans have also almost universally praised this song, as is shown by its ranking as "The Very Best" by [[Teenage Victory Songs]], a popular Weezer songblog. Allmusic.com gave "Undone" a [[Undone - The Sweater Song Allmusic track review|5 star rating]] and also named it an "AMG Track Pick."
"Undone" is one of Weezer's most popular songs. The track reached 57 on the US Billboard Hot 100 List of 1994. Allmusic.com gave "Undone" a [[Undone - The Sweater Song Allmusic track review|5 star rating]] and also named it an "AMG Track Pick."
 
==Audio==
==Versions==
===Demos===
*[[The Kitchen Tape]] demo <br>
<youtube>VMO5d-_x4mQ</youtube> <youtube>oD0JS0gi0Fs</youtube>
An early demo, officially released on the 2004 Deluxe Edition of ''[[The Blue Album]]''.
===Live===
*[[The Real Demo]] version <br>
<youtube>o_FqVnY6eYo</youtube>
From the band's third and final demo, this version features some of the early samples employed by Karl, and is a glimpse into the unreleased studio version.  This version is being cirulated as an mp3 on the internet.
*LP version
*promo edit(s) <br>
Initially, when edited for promotional radio CDs, the song was incorrectly pared down to 3:58, featuring a drastic edit of the ride-out guitar solo.  The band, particularly Rivers, wanted a certain 4:10 edit, featuring a more smoothly edited guitar solo, and so the correct edit was summarily produced on all future promos.  However, a great many of the incorrect promos were made and sent out, so that the incorrect version is actually the more common one, with the correct 4:10 edit a collector's item.  Both edits also fade out early, after the main song ends, eliminating the drawn-out collage of sounds.
*video edit <br>
The version used in the video retains the full guitar solo of the LP version, but also employs the early fade-out as featured on the previously mentioned edits.
*MTV Live version <br>
A session recorded for MTV's '120 Minutes' program, and released in 1998 on ''[[MTV's 120 Minutes Live]]'' compilation.
 
==Tracklist==
==Track listing==
==Track listing==
{| class="wikitable"
{| class="wikitable"