Template:Pinkerton reviews
| Reviewer | Rating | Review date | Author |
|---|---|---|---|
| Allmusic |  (5/5)
|
Not listed | Stephen Thomas Erlewine |
| Amazon | Not given | Not listed | Robert Burrow |
| CDUniverse | Not given | Not listed | Unsigned |
| IGN |  (9.5/10)
|
December 21, 2007 | "JR" |
| Los Angeles Times |  (3.0/5)
|
Unknown | Unknown |
| NME | (7.0/10)
|
Unknown | Unknown |
| The Onion A.V. Club | Not given | November 30, 2009 | Josh Modell |
| Pitchfork Media | (7.5/10)
|
September, 1996 | Ryan Schreiber |
| Pitchfork Media (Deluxe) | (10.0/10)
|
November 3, 2010 | Ian Cohen |
| Q | (4.0/5)
|
Unknown | Unknown |
| Rolling Stone (1996) | (3.0/5)
|
1996 | Rob O'Conner |
| Rolling Stone (2004) | (5.0/5)
|
December 9, 2004 | Gavin Edwards |
| Spin | (7.0/10)
|
Unknown | Unknown |
| Tiny Mix Tapes | (5.0/5)
|
Not listed | "cowboy dan" |
| Dayton Daily News | (1.0/5)
|
October 11, 1996 | Ray Marcano |
| Stereogum | No rating given | April 21, 2016 | Tom Breihan |